- Margaret,* a CHP member with bipolar disorder...
- Jim,* suffers from a very rare neurological disease...
- Bill,* a person with developmental disabilities and a recovering alcoholic...
- Eleanor,* has been confined to her bed for the past five years...
- Art,* a 77-year old divorced Korean War veteran...
- Sally,* a 31-year old woman with Cerebral Palsy...
* Not member's real names
Margaret
Margaret, a CHP member with Bipolar disorder has complications from a previous stroke and brain tumor -
causing issues with her gait, motor skills, and cognition. In the first year and a half of enrollment,
she had 20 ER visits and 11 hospitalizations, most of which were for suicidal ideation and management of
Bipolar symptoms. Two group home placements were tried but did not work out. She was not happy being away
from her family and home, and continued to have ER visits/hospitalizations. Cooperatively, Margaret's Team and
CHP's Behavioral Health Services began to focus on keeping her in a home environment. Working with an adult day program,
county social worker, psychiatrist, transportation sources, and in-home service providers, supports were put in place
to meet her needs while helping her to learn and improve coping skills, and identify and deal with her stressors.
The Team also provided support for her spouse to prevent caregiver burnout. As part of her ongoing evaluation,
concerns about cognitive decline/dementia were identified with both county staff and a psychiatrist recommending
guardianship. CHP advocated for Margaret and it was discovered that her cognitive changes were medication related.
After these concerns were addressed, she returned to a normal baseline without a need for guardianship.
Overall, Margaret's medical costs dropped from an average of $8000/mo to less than $4000/mo. Monthly hospital costs
went from a high of $10,160 to zero in six months time. She has had one episode of mild suicidal
thought, but with her Team, CHP's Behavioral Health Services and Community Support Program intervention, her concerns
have been dealt with without a need for hospitalization. She is happy to be able to live at home with her family
and feels a sense of achievement by learning to manage her symptoms and feels supported in the community.
Jim
Jim suffers from a very rare neurological disease. The disease, most often seen in children,
is fatal. In the process of searching for treatments, Jim was excited to learn about an experimental drug
being used to treat the condition and asked his CHP Team to make arrangements to receive treatments with this
medication. Unfortunately, the request for the drug was initially denied due to the lack of published research
as to its effectiveness. Jim felt strongly enough about obtaining the drug and filed an appeal with CHP's
Grievance & Appeal Committee. CHP consulted with a local family practice physician, regarding the drug's use.
The physician indicated the drug therapy could be an effective treatment and recommended its use.
CHP's Grievance & Appeal committee felt strongly that approval of the drug's use was an excellent example of
CHP's commitment to serving people with complex needs and upheld the member's appeal. Because the supply of the
drug is so limited in the United States and is primarily reserved for children, the process to obtain it
required Jim be enrolled in a special Temporary Access Program, a measure implemented to manage supply and
usage for adults. Jim's treatments require a trip to a Minneapolis, MN, hospital once every two weeks to
receive a three-hour IV therapy. A homecare worker accompanies Jim and assists him with meals and toileting.
Since receiving this medication, incredible progress has been made. Jim can now stand completely unassisted
and general mobility continues to improve along with overall endurance, range of motion, and balance.
He now uses a manual wheelchair at home and is able to sleep more often in a normal bed.
This scenario is a perfect example of CHP's ability to do the right thing, at the right time, for the right
reasons.
Bill
Bill, a person with developmental disabilities and a recovering alcoholic, resides in a trailer
home on a small hobby farm. He frequently interacts with his mother who lives in another trailer home nearby.
In addition to cooking all his meals, Bill's mother handles all his finances. At times,
this has been a particular challenge, as close relatives have been known to take advantage of Bill
by diverting some of the few dollars the member does have for themselves.
Bill and his mother own several horses and care for them on a daily basis. They also handle horses for other
local horse owners. A favorite outing for them is to attend one of many horse pulls held in Wisconsin and
neighboring states. When he initially became a CHP member, CHP staff found Bill's personal living conditions
to be deplorable. His trailer home was scattered with cat feces and garbage, and litter was piled up in many
places. Black mold covered the walls of the bathroom and several holes could be found in the floor throughout
the trailer. During the Team's initial visits, staff would meet with Bill at his mother's trailer home as they
were unable to withstand the smell in the trailer. Under medication for his epilepsy, Bill was prone to
forgetfulness and undisciplined in adhering to the correct dosage - often taking all his meds in the morning
instead of twice a day as prescribed by his doctor. His personal hygiene was also very poor.
While he had many health and living condition issues, Bill was aware of the problems and advised his CHP team
early on that the trailer needed to be cleaned and new flooring put in. At the advice of his clinical team,
he cleaned out all of the feces and cat litter over the first few months. It took nearly five months, but he
finally agreed to have a bath twice a week. He also agreed to take his medications appropriately.
He eventually put new flooring in his trailer and through a small financial grant, was able to replace his
furnace.
Eleanor
Eleanor has been confined to her bed for the past five years. She has resided in her home
with assistance from her son who lives with her and is her activated POA-HC.
Her son has been her caregiver for the past 50 years and has provided excellent care with the opportunity
to have control of all aspects of her daily living. Eleanor along with her son and her Community Health
Partnership team have worked together to develop and implement a plan to provide all services and supplies
necessary to support her goal of remaining in her home. When Eleanor fractured her hip, it resulted in frequent
transitions between the hospital and a local nursing home due to pain control issues, mobility issues,
skin breakdown, decreased levels of consciousness, and nutritional and respiratory complications.
She was hospitalized multiple times due to these complications and did not have a DNR determination
per her son's request. Other family members, medical professionals, as well as hospital and nursing home staff,
encouraged the member's son to keep his mother in the hospital or nursing home and to provide
comfort measures until she passes away. This created intense differences of opinion, especially
with his concerns regarding cares provided by the hospital and nursing home.
Throughout all her health care episodes, when Eleanor has been alert, she has continued to have a positive
attitude, humor, a warm smile and touch, and a sparkle in her eye. Her goal remains the same -
to live the rest of her life in the home she loves. As a result, there have been ongoing conversations
and meetings between the son, other family members, Palliative Care, the Community Health Partnership
Team, and the physician. One objective was to assist the son in understanding and accepting his mother's
end-of-life status and related issues. Another objective was to continue to provide the best care possible
for Eleanor. A conference was held among the son and other family members, the hospital's Palliative Care
coordinator, Community Health Partnership Team, the physician and a local hospice agency. The hospice
philosophy was explained to the son with the result that he understood and accepted his mother's end-of-life
issues. He also understood that the hospice agency and Community Health Partnership Team would continue to
work together to provide all necessary equipment and services in their home to meet the wishes of the member to
live out her life in her home. This program will also provide the son the opportunity to once again be
involved in caring for his mother and allowing input and control regarding her cares like he has done for
the past 50 years and has sorely missed. As a result of five months of meetings and counseling, hospital
discharge has been planned and our member will now be able to meet her goal to live out her days in the home
she loves, surrounded by all the fond memories that her home and family offer her.
Art
Art, a 77-year old divorced Korean War veteran, enrolled with CHP in the Fall of 2006 following
a debilitating stroke. After placement in a nursing home, Art, an admitted free spirit,
directed his team to help him pursue only one goal, and it came with a definite contingency: having a
place of his own with no interference in his private affairs. Unfortunately, significant impairments
compromised his goal. His mobility, strength, speech, and swallowing were all highly impaired. His diabetes
was uncontrolled. A serious cardiac history, alcoholism, and failure to thrive all contributed to his
instability and frailty. A feeding tube accommodated all food, hydration and medications. No one involved
in his care could envision or support anything but permanent nursing home placement. The more his
caregivers insisted he stay in the nursing home, the harder he pushed back. He became verbally abusive
and physically aggressive towards staff. He would often leave the facility during day hours and return
inebriated at night. He alienated his only remaining extended family as well as friends. Against
medical advice, Art left the nursing home refusing any planning or assistance. He checked into a motel,
resumed oral food and liquids, refused all medications including Coumadin, and attempted his own personal
care. He soon found himself unable to manage his situation and called upon the motel staff to pick him
up off the floor, clean up after incontinence episodes, help him into and out of bed, and do errands.
This behavior initiated a series of moves from one motel to the next until he was soon "black listed"
in the entire community for trashing rooms, abusing staff, and fee non-payment. Throughout this time,
he demanded that CHP resolve his dilemmas but refused or sabotaged every effort of assistance, even eventually
"firing" his team. Police, social service, home care agencies, transportation companies, and housing
authorities refused him service. Eventually he spent day hours
in a drop-in center and nights elsewhere on his own. He refused all
efforts to find housing, since all potential landlords required paperwork and personal information.
Numerous medical emergencies occurred. Following a hospitalization for failure to thrive, uncontrolled
diabetes and malnutrition, the Team persuaded him to try a small group home. After two months, he
left the home only to continue his abrasive, abusive, and risk-taking behaviors. He soon found nothing
but closed doors to additional resources and assistance. During one crisis after another, his CHP
Team performed a delicate and difficult balancing act between intervention and boundary-setting.
They struggled over their roles and responsibilities and their member's right to choose.
They felt responsible for the consequences of his poor decisions. They became frustrated with a
community that didn't know how to help yet insisted that CHP solve his many problems. During the
first eight months of this experience with CHP, monthly medical costs averaged over $8200. In time,
our member's alienated sister resolved to reconnect. He accepted her help in finding a mobile home
to rent. The CHP team immediately sought ways to support the move by providing DME equipment, a hospital bed,
a ramp, a power-lift chair, a scooter, and in-home rehab services. He accepted pharmacy set-up and delivery
service, Meals-on-Wheels, and the guidance of a dietitian. A new physician was able to provide medical support. Behaviors
improved and more extended family entered his life. One of them was hired by CHP as a Family
Caregiver and visited daily to provide care and assistance. These relationships have been pivotal
to other successes. On his own, our member stopped drinking entirely. His feeding tube was removed by
his physician, and he began gaining weight. He now has new mobility freedom with his ramp and scooter
and even uses city transportation for weekly senior center visits where he socializes and exercises.
He is content and happy. Through unyielding determination, our member defied the collective "wisdom" and
"guidance" of many well-meaning service providers who thought they knew best. Science, logic, and
reasoning said that he would not survive outside the nursing home setting.
Yet he not only has survived, he has thrived. With the consistent support of his CHP Team,
the only entity that stood by him through it all, he has made an independent life for himself.
His medical costs for the second eight months with CHP have averaged a little over $1900 per month - a savings
of over $6000 per month! The Team continues to stand ready to move quickly and
efficiently when another support opportunity presents itself, while simultaneously respecting
his right to self-direct. It's difficult to describe the frustration and self-doubt that accompanied
this journey. Set-backs and crises caused great discouragement and feelings of hopelessness and helplessness
for everyone involved. Throughout it all, our member kept his focus on, and finally achieved, his one
and only goal.
Sally
Sally, a 31-year old woman with Cerebral Palsy, limited motor skills, and the ability to speak
only with the assistance of a voice liberator was looking for a different place to live.
Dependent on caregivers for most of her daily living activities, this CHP member was dealing with a
number of other medical complications. Due to her intense care needs, she had been cared for in highly-staffed
assisted living settings for much of her adult life. This young woman had struggled to acclimate
to the routines of congregated living. Personal choices such as regularly attending church, time limited
access to the Internet, and other interpersonal struggles with caregivers had left her frustrated. Sally and
her CHP care team began investigating the possibility of finding a home and offering her the opportunity
to choose her caregivers through CHP's Self-Directed Supports option. After several months of planning, she
chose to hire family and friends to care for her at her parent's home, which was modified to accommodate
her physical disabilities. Since moving into her parents' residence, she has become more actively involved
with her church and with the assistance of a church member, has begun taking piano lessons in her home. She
also continues to look for volunteer opportunities in hopes of gaining experience to acquire a job.
|